Frogs, coalitions, and mining: Transformative insights for planetary health and earth system law from Ecuador’s struggle to enforce Nature’s rights

Author links open overlay panel Carlos Andres Gallegos-Riofrío abc, Mario A. Moncayo-Altamirano d , Andrea Terán-Valdez e,  Gustavo Redin-Guerrero f ,  Carlos Varela d, Stephen Posner g, Amaya Carrasco-Torrontegui bch

Atelpus longirostris frog side view

Abstract

Pachamama, Mother Earth, faces a mass extinction threat. A radical transformation in human systems is essential, guided by equity and justice at local and global scales. This transformation must reconfigure the World-System’s power structures, impacting the ecosphere (ecological functions, biodiversity, and resource regimes) and the ethnosphere (ontological, epistemological, and legal pluralism). Together, these shape the Pluriverse—a planet of many worlds. The status quo is unsustainable. Effective solutions must prioritize a just transition that integrates the pluriverse. Alternatives from the so-called Global South offer valuable tools for this shift, such as the Rights of Nature, which views nature as a rights-bearing entity, not merely an object of regulation. The Llurimagua case—a dispute over a mining concession in Ecuador’s cloud forest—illustrates this approach, providing a unique opportunity to rethink Earth System Governance and address the Anthropocene Gap (i.e., disconnect with Earth System Law), crucial for tackling planetary health challenges.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2589811625000199?fbclid=IwY2xjawJ2udFleHRuA2FlbQIxMQABHlavHsZa60ISu-EVvGuwn2KBL3Q2941h6ziHkiKhzqIkmilFYUIQ8g1CGImv_aem_o0wfJmpmKEgGv6FpXqFAVQ&sfnsn=scwspwa

Carlos Zorrilla

Resident of Intag since 1978. Member of DECOIN since 1995

Leave a Reply