
Intag, 2019. Anti-mining assembly, one of dozens held to collectively reject mining in the region.
Since the 1990s, five transnational mining companies have failed to overcome the resistance of the communities and organizations of Intag. Three of them failed in Llurimagua alone, the project that the Noboa government now promises to put out to tender in early 2027.
Intag has become a graveyard for mining companies.

The next to fail could be one of the four companies that, according to the government, are interested in joining the quagmire: BHP (which was unable to begin operations in Intag in 2022-2023), Teck, South32, and Chinalco. Hanrine, the Ecuadorian subsidiary of the Australian company Hancock Prospecting , would be a fifth contender, although it hasn’t been seen in the area since acquiring six concessions in Intag in 2024. The sixth could be Boroo Pte Ltd, from Singapore, which in mid-2026 bought the concessions of Codelco’s Ecuadorian subsidiary, EMSAEC, the company that invested in advanced exploration in the Toisán mountain range since 2013 and, like its predecessors, ended up leaving.
It won’t be easy for any of them. In the 1990s, with just one environmental organization (DECOIN) opposed to mining, communities managed to expel Bishimetals, a powerful Japanese mining company that had the full backing of the Ecuadorian government. Today, more than twenty organizations reject mining and promote sustainable economic activities in Intag. Llurimagua has also accumulated three international arbitrations, a record in Ecuador and Latin America, and its deposit, presented as one of the largest in the world, has never been evaluated by an independent entity or under standards such as NI 43-101. It could be another Bre-X, the infamous scam that deceived thousands of Canadian investors.
These, then, are the 25 reasons why investing in Intag is a bad idea for any mining company.
A. Environmental and social impacts
The impacts in this section come from the Preliminary Environmental Impact Assessment for a small copper mine (450,000 tons), fully funded by the Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)². It is the only environmental impact assessment for a mining project in Ecuador that has not been paid for by mining companies and, therefore, the only objective study conducted on site. Years later, the Japanese inferred that the deposit could be five times larger, and in 2020 the government estimated up to eleven times more copper: therefore, The real impacts would be much greater if these rough estimates are real.
1. Relocation. Intag is not the Atacama Desert, where Codelco has its mines: in addition to forests of enormous biodiversity, it is home to dozens of farming communities. The study anticipates relocating hundreds of families from at least four communities, a number that would increase with a larger deposit. The relocation of communities alone is enough to halt almost any extractive project.
2. Primary cloud forests. Less than 2.5% of tropical forests are cloud forests. They are among the most biodiverse and threatened ecosystems on the planet, and are essential for protecting the water supply of Andean communities and stabilizing the climate.
3. Massive deforestation. That’s how Japanese experts described the degree of deforestation needed to accommodate the mine. The Japanese-government funded study calculated that the small mine would directly affect 4,025 hectares of biodiverse forests and rich watersheds. Industrial mining in this ecosystem would openly violate the Rights of Nature enshrined in the 2008 Ecuadorian Constitution.
4. Desertification.The term the Japanese scientists used to describe the effects of massive deforestation.According to the same study, deforestation would dry out the local climate and consequently affect thousands of small farmers.
5. Species on the brink of extinction. The Intag forests belong to the Tropical Andes, the world’s most important biodiversity hotspot. To date, 104 threatened species have been identified within the concession, including the jaguar, the Andean bear, the Andean eagle, the collared peccary, eight orchid species, and three monkey species: the howler monkey, the white-faced capuchin, and the brown-headed spider monkey, one of the 25 most endangered primates on the planet. Thirty-four frog species are on the red list , including the long-snouted harlequin frog ( Atelopus longirostris ), rediscovered in 2016, and a new species of the genus Ectopoglossus (2019), which have only been reported within the mining area. Biologist Bitty Roy and other scientists have identified more than 200 threatened species in the area ( https://bit.ly/2ORqcvV) .

Seven of the 104 threatened species threatened with extinction.
6. Water. The concession contains rivers and streams. The Japanese study predicted their contamination with lead, arsenic, chromium, cadmium, and other toxic substances present in the deposit; recent studies have also detected mercury in the soil.
7. Archaeological Heritage. All environmental impact studies conducted by various companies (the most recent in 2018) identify unexplored pre-Incan archaeological sites within the concession area. Their destruction is a crime in Ecuador.
8. Cotacachi-Cayapas National Park. The entire concession is located within the buffer zone of this park, one of the protected areas with the greatest biological diversity in the world according to the Japanese study itself.
B. Legal obstacles
9. Ecological Canton and Court Rulings. Large-scale mining would violate the binding declaration of Cotacachi as an Ecological Canton (2000), the validity of which can only be reviewed by the Constitutional Court, which has not done so. Furthermore, on November 30, 2021, the communities filed a constitutional action for the violation of the rights of nature and the lack of prior environmental consultation. In March 2023, the Provincial Court of Imbabura ruled in their favor, ordering the suspension of all mining activity and revoking the environmental license; in 2024, the Constitutional Court ratified the ruling. Since then, no mining activity has taken place.
Three international arbitrations: a warning for investors
Codelco filed two arbitration cases against Ecuador for failing to fulfill its obligation to develop the Llurimagua mine through a new joint venture with the state-owned mining company ENAMI. The first , filed in 2021 with the International Chamber of Commerce (Paris), concluded in 2025 with a significant defeat for Codelco: of the nearly $600 million claimed, it received only $25.3 million, and the tribunal ruled that it was not obligated to hand over its geological information for the concession. The second , filed with the International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID) in January 2022, remained unresolved as of November 2026. These cases are in addition to the Copper Mesa arbitration against Ecuador (2013), depicted in the film “The Tribunal .” The lesson is clear: Ecuador is a great place to invest in mining if you don’t mind losing all, or almost all, of your investment.
10. Rights of Nature, Sumak Kawsay, and Prior Consultation. The Constitution recognizes nature’s right to exist, thrive and regenerate; species like the Long-Nose Harlequin, as well as the Intag Resistance Frog are just two of the species that will always present a constitutional obstacle to opening a mine. Ecuador’s Constitution also guarantees the right to Sumak Kawsay, or Good Living. And, if that wasn’t enough, the Organic Environmental Code considers cloud forests a essential fragile ecosystems to guarantee said right. Finally, the communities have never been legally consulted, as required by Article 398. Communities in Azuay and Sucumbíos and the Waorani people of Pastaza have already won against the State for lack of prior consultation.
The Los Cedros precedent. In 2021, the Constitutional Court ruled in favor of the rights of nature and the right to environmental consultation regarding the project by the Canadian company Cornerstone in the Los Cedros Protected Forest, adjacent to Llurimagua and sharing the same habitat (114 threatened species have been identified there). The company had to abandon the project, and the ruling established a precedent directly applicable to Intag.
11. More layers of protection. In 2019, the Municipality of Cotacachi created the Intag-Toisán Municipal Conservation and Sustainable Use Area (ACUSMIT), which excludes mining. That same year UNESCO declared the entire province of Imbabura a Global Geopark, the first in Ecuador, to be managed under the guidlines of conservation, education, and tourism. In 2024, Cotacachi declared Intag a Sanctuary of Life , with further restrictions on mining. In addition, there are 38 community-owned and administered watershed reserves, protecting more than 12,000 hectares. All are managed by local communities and local governments—a model promoted by DECOIN which helped it earned the United Nations Development Programme’s Equator Prize in 2017.
C. Civil Society Opposition

Part of the EcoJunin ecotourism group, which has been using the forest in the mining concession for decades
12. More than 30 years of mobilization. The mining threat has mobilized more than 90% of the local, cantonal, and national organizations in the area. What once affected only Junín now affects all of Intag due to the irresponsible granting of concessions throughout the region.
13. A seasoned resistance. Three decades of struggle have honed the legal capacity of the communities, who refuse to surrender. The right to resistance is protected by the Constitution. Bishimetals (Japan), Copper Mesa (Canada), Cornerstone (Canada), BHP (Australia-United Kingdom), and Codelco (Chile), in addition to the state-owned ENAMI, have not been able to open a single mine in the region.
14. An explicit and documented rejection. The main organizations in Intag wrote to the presidents of Chile on three occasions, warning that they would defend the area if Codelco proceeded. In 2021, most of them delivered a letter to the concessionary companies, President Lasso, and the Ministers of Environment and Energy regarding the project’s risks. Six presidents of parish councils formally objected to the Ministry of the Environment because a Codelco concession overlapped with the Nangulví Bajo community reserve. And in November 2014, 100,000 signatures from citizens around the world were delivered to the Chilean Consulate in Germany.
Mining and violence. Mining has been associated with human rights abuses and violence. In December 2006, for example, Canadian Copper Mesa, hired dozens of paramilitaries in a failed attempt to gain access to its mining concession. They failed completely and community members arrested 57 of them and turned them over to the police (see the documentary Under Rich Earth). And then, in 2014, after failing to convince the communities of the wonders of the mining project, the government deployed nearly 400 police and military personnel to impose the project violating all kinds of human rights. The mining camp was violently set up in the Junín community forest reserve that the community had been using for tourism for decades; the exploration activities felled centuries-old trees, contaminated water sources, and severely impacted community tourism (see the Comptroller’s Report of March 2019 and the documentary Codelco in Intag ).
D. Technical and economic risks
15. An Inflated Deposit. In 2007, Micon International, contracted by Ascendant Copper (later Copper Mesa) to evaluate the deposit based on the Japanese exploratory results. Curiously, it stated that it could not confirm previous estimates due to sample degradation. Copper Mesa claimed there was double the amount of copper than the Japanese had deduced after years of exploration: 2.26 million tons of inferred copper, but that amount has never been verified tons. This amount is less than one-tenth of annual global consumption. Inferred resources are the least reliable category in a mining project; even so, the government speaks of 5.4 million tons, and Codelco used its own figures without independent studies. Until an independent evaluation of the drilling is conducted, none of these figures should be considered valid.
16. Extreme Rainfall and Tailings. The area receives between 2,000 and 5,000 mm of rain annually. Intense rainfall, abundant groundwater, and heavy metals from the mine are a dangerous combination that increases the cost of any project and multiplies the risk of landslides and tailings dam failures, like those in Brazil (2015 and 2019) that killed nearly 300 people. After visiting Llurimagua, engineer Steven Emerman of Malach Consulting concluded that the risk of tailings dam failures there was “the worst of the worst” he had ever seen.
17. Perpetual contamination. The deposit is porphyry and contains arsenic and other heavy metals, which would generate acid mine drainage, a type of contamination that never stops.
18. Excess groundwater. The Japanese study documents that it significantly increases mining costs and causes enormous environmental problems.
19. Extremely rugged topography. This increases the costs of large-scale mining and the risk of tailings dam collapses, landslides, and consequently, water pollution.
20. A deep deposit. According to the 1998 Japanese report, copper is found at great depths, making mining more destructive and less profitable.
21. Seismic risk. Ecuador, in general, is a very active sismic country. The Toisán mountain range, where the ore body is located, is crossed by numerous geological faults. Mining is already dangerous in non sismic zones. Seismicity greatly increases the risks of major accidents.
E. Legal and reputational risks
22. Reports from the Comptroller General’s Office and the Ombudsman’s Office. In March 2019, the Comptroller General’s Office documented dozens of serious violations committed by the company and public officials during Codelco’s more than four years of operation in the Junín forest, and called attention to the regulatory bodies for failing to demand the project’s cancellation. In May 2019, the Ombudsman’s Office denounced serious violations of human and collective rights. Both reports may support future legal action.
23. Lethal Copper. When wealthy countries create stronger mechanisms to exclude critical minerals for the energy transition associated with serious environmental, governance or social impacts, Intag’s copper will be high on the list. Organizations will ensure that Junin’s copper it is seen for what it is: lethal copper , linked to human rights violations, the devastation of one of the most biodiverse forests on the planet, species extinction, the destruction of cultural heritage, and the displacement of rural communities.
24. International support. From the beginning, the resistance has had the backing of prestigious international entities; even actor Leonardo DiCaprio has joined the global alert about this project.
25. New mandatory consultations. All this legal and social opposition arose during the exploration phase. Moving to exploitation, with its far greater impacts, would require new prior consultation processes. Given Intag’s history, it is virtually impossible for the communities, or the courts, to approve the opening of the mine. The only certainty is that opposition will intensify at all levels.
Conclusion
There are more than 25 reasons for companies to stay away from Intag, but these are enough to warn any investor who dares to take on Llurimagua: they will be considered complicit in unprecedented environmental devastation, the extinction of species, and serious human rights abuses, in a place so socially conflictive and ecologically fragile that it has already expelled five transnational corporations.
1. In 1998 the Japanese inferred the presence of 2.26 million tons of copper, but they never finished the exploration and, to date, the deposit has not been verified.
2. Final report on mineral exploration for technical cooperation in the Junín and Cuellaje areas, March 1996, JICA and Metal Mining Agency of Japan. https://openjicareport.jica.go.jp/pdf/11282761_01.pdf (accessed November 2026).